The Social Security cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) has become a contentious issue, leaving many seniors struggling to make ends meet.
With insufficient increases failing to keep pace with inflation and rising living costs, some retirees are exploring the possibility of returning to the workforce as a means of supplementing their income.
Seniors Facing Financial Pressure Amid Low COLA
A recent poll conducted by The Motley Fool sheds light on the gravity of the situation. Among 2,000 American retirees surveyed, a staggering 50% reported they were considering returning to work due to financial challenges.
While part-time or flexible work offers potential benefits—like additional income, better health insurance, and opportunities for social engagement—the prevalence of such considerations underscores the inadequacy of current Social Security adjustments.
The 2024 COLA of just 2.5% has been particularly disappointing. For seniors already living on tight budgets, the adjustment barely scratches the surface of their financial needs.
Critics argue that the methodology for calculating COLA, based on the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W), is fundamentally flawed.
The CPI-W reflects spending patterns of younger workers, which differ significantly from those of retirees. Advocates suggest a shift to the CPI-E, a measure tailored to individuals aged 62 and older, as a more accurate reflection of seniors’ financial realities.
Social Security Payments and Their Limited Reach
In 2024, the average monthly Social Security payment stands at $1,907—a sum that falls dramatically short of covering the typical retiree’s expenses. For context, Americans aged 65 and older spent an average of $5,007 per month in 2023.
While Social Security was never designed to fully fund retirement, it was expected to cover about 40% of expenses. However, a significant portion of retirees rely on these benefits for the majority—or even the entirety—of their income:
- 28% rely exclusively on Social Security.
- 32% depend on it for more than half of their income.
This reliance highlights the urgency of addressing the COLA shortcomings and bolstering financial stability for seniors.
The Case for Change: Moving to CPI-E
Organizations like the Senior Citizens League (TSCL) have been vocal about the inadequacies of the current COLA system. Their research indicates that Social Security benefits in 2024 have lost approximately 20% of their purchasing power compared to 2010.
According to Shannon Benton, executive director of TSCL, the reliance on the CPI-W is a missed opportunity to provide meaningful relief to retirees. TSCL advocates for:
- Switching to CPI-E: Better reflects seniors’ actual expenses.
- Implementing a minimum COLA: A baseline adjustment of at least 3% to ensure seniors keep pace with inflation.
TSCL’s findings are alarming: 67% of seniors depend on Social Security for the majority of their income, and 62% worry their retirement funds won’t cover basic necessities like food and medical care.
Working After Retirement: A New Reality?
Returning to the workforce is increasingly viewed as a financial necessity rather than a choice. While some retirees find personal fulfillment, structure, or social connections through work, financial stability remains the dominant motivator.
Jack Caporal, research lead at The Motley Fool, noted that retirees often work to sustain their lifestyles. Yet this trend also underscores deeper systemic issues—retirement should not mean sacrificing dignity or security.
Ensuring sustainable COLAs could reduce this financial pressure and allow more retirees to enjoy their later years without needing to re-enter the workforce.
Looking Ahead: Strengthening Retirement Security
The debate over Social Security COLAs touches on broader questions about how the U.S. can better support its aging population.
While adjustments like adopting the CPI-E or instituting a minimum COLA are promising solutions, real change requires Congressional action. Seniors, advocates, and policymakers must work together to secure retirement benefits that reflect the true cost of living.
Also See: Social Security’s Black Friday Gift – $943 Official Check for Black Friday and Cyber Monday Shopping
FAQs
1. What is the Social Security COLA?
The COLA is an annual adjustment to Social Security benefits designed to offset inflation by increasing payments to match rising living costs.
2. Why is the CPI-W criticized for COLA calculations?
The CPI-W tracks spending by urban wage earners and clerical workers, whose expenses differ significantly from seniors, resulting in adjustments that don’t align with retirees’ actual needs.
3. What is the CPI-E?
The CPI-E (Consumer Price Index for the Elderly) adjusts spending data to better reflect the costs typically incurred by people aged 62 and older, such as healthcare and housing.
4. How much of their income do most retirees get from Social Security?
Research indicates that 67% of seniors rely on Social Security for more than half their income, and 28% depend on it entirely.
5. Why are seniors returning to work?
Many retirees consider working again to supplement their income due to insufficient Social Security benefits, rising costs, and a desire to maintain their standard of living.